1. Home
  2. Analysis
  3. Stock
Stock

Only Alphabet and Apple Have Beaten the S&P 500 Since 2025 as Nvidia's Beat Fades

Since early 2025, only two Magnificent Seven stocks have beaten the S&P 500's ~29% gain. Nvidia's earnings bounce faded as yields stay above 5%.

BMInsider desk · · 3 min read
Close-up of a single glowing server rack aisle in a modern data center hall, seen from low angle down the corridor, with one lit rack standing out against rows of darker ones.

Only two of the Magnificent Seven stocks have beaten the S&P 500 since the start of 2025, according to a MarketWatch tally reported Nov. 18. Alphabet is up about 51% and Apple about 42%, against roughly 29% for the index, as reported in reprints of the piece. For investors holding an index fund, that means the result rests on a narrow group of winners.

What happened

Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla all trail the index over that stretch, per the same reports. Nvidia's laggard status stands out.

Note the timeframe. Earlier coverage of calendar-year 2025 named Alphabet and Nvidia as the two outperformers. Measured since the start of 2025, the reported pair is Alphabet and Apple. The original MarketWatch article could not be retrieved, so these figures come from secondary reprints.

Nvidia reported fiscal third-quarter results this week, and Reuters said its sales forecast beat expectations. It was the first report since Jensen Huang stepped down as CEO. Futures rose overnight, but CNBC's live coverage showed the Dow down about 400 points as the bounce fizzled.

The S&P 500 fell 1.0% on Tuesday, according to Reuters. The 10-year Treasury yield was about 5.10%. St. Louis Fed President Alberto Musalem said the Fed may need several rate hikes to bring inflation under control and should act soon.

Why it matters

The gap shows how concentrated the index has become. A rise driven by two stocks tells you little about the other five giants.

Three explanations are plausible, though none is proven. Yields above 5% weigh on companies whose profits lie far in the future. Investors are also questioning returns on heavy AI spending. Carew of Tandem Investment Advisors told MarketWatch that Apple avoided playing "the same game" as the others, and credited Alphabet's rise to a sharp reversal in sentiment, partly tied to its TPU chip business.

The Anthropic IPO may also be pulling capital. Salesforce plunged 9.7% as the IPO stirred a software rout. That is a pattern, not proof of cause.

What to watch next

  • The Fed's Dec. 8-9 meeting: a hike is already priced, and the debate is over 25bp versus 50bp.
  • The 10-year yield: whether it holds above 5% or eases.
  • Anthropic's trading debut and any further pressure on software shares.
  • Whether Nvidia's guidance lifts Microsoft, Amazon and Meta, or only chip suppliers.
  • Nvidia's leadership picture after Huang's exit.

This is a look at the performance gap, not a recommendation.

Stocks in this analysis

AI stock analysis

Free on aktienanalyse.ai: score profile, ratios versus the industry and business model. Plus, if you want it, the full analysis with fair value and bull, base and bear case. Prices and ratios as of Nov 17, 2026.

Sources (5)
  1. Only two 'Magnificent Seven' stocks have managed to beat the S&P 500 since the start of 2025 (MarketWatch reprint, Longbridge)
  2. Dow falls 400 points as Nvidia earnings bounce fizzles – CNBC
  3. Stocks slip as investors mull Nvidia earnings; Anthropic IPO to test AI boom – Reuters via Kitco
  4. Stock Market Today: Nvidia's 26% Plunge Puts Wall Street on Edge – 24/7 Wall St.
  5. Meet the Only Magnificent Seven Stock That's Outperforming – Motley Fool

This analysis is for information only and is not investment advice. Prices and figures as of publication.

AI stock analysis

Any stock analysed in minutes

Business model, balance sheet, valuation and scenarios: aktienanalyse.ai builds a thorough analysis of any stock in minutes, with a fair value and bull, base and bear cases.

Analyse a stock → Stock profiles